CBS Argues That Halftime Show Was Not Indecent
September 12, 2007

At Tuesday's "nipplegate" hearing before the U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia, CBS Corp. argued that it should not be held liable for the 2004 Super Bowl halftime show that ended with Janet Jackson's breast-baring "wardrobe malfunction" because the stunt was both unscripted and unintended. CBS also said that if the FCC's $550,000 fine is upheld, it will effectively censor U.S. broadcasting. CBS lawyer Robert Corn-Revere urged the court to overturn the fine and said the ruling has had a "profoundly censorious effect" on U.S. broadcasting by deterring stations from showing material that could possibly be considered indecent, according to Reuters. The network feels that by fining them, the FCC has abandoned its policy of avoiding penalties for "fleeting" or "isolated" images.

However, FCC attorney Eric Miller defended the decision that the halftime show was indecent because it was a "highly sexualized performance" even before the brief breast exposure. Miller claims that CBS had been "willful" in its broadcast because it failed to guard against indecency. He said the National Football League had expressed concern beforehand about the sexually charged performance and that Jackson's choreographer said in advance the show would contain "some shocking moments." "CBS was indifferent to the fact that an obvious risk can constitute a deliberate omission," Miller argued, according to Reuters.

Miller also said that Jackson and halftime co-star Justin Timberlake were employees of CBS, therefore the network should have to pay for their actions. However, Julio Fuentes, one member of the three-judge panel, challenged that claim. "That doesn't make sense at all," Fuentes said, according to Reuters. "They were not employees of CBS, were they?"

The network immediately apologized after the incident aired and both Jackson and Timberlake confirmed they planned it "independently and clandestinely" without informing anyone, according to court documents. At the time, Jackson released a statement saying, "The decision to have a costume reveal at the end of my halftime show was made after final rehearsals. [Halftime show producer] MTV was completely unaware of it. It was not my intention that it go as far as it did."

The court is expected to rule in the coming months but it did not indicate exactly when.




 
Breaking News
Nielsen Mid-Year Report: Overall U.S. Music Consumption Up 14%
July 2, 2015
Report: Facebook In Talks With Major Labels
In Brief - July 2, 2015
July 1, 2015
American General Media Names Picazzo Stevens PD At KAGM & KDLW/Albuquerque
Brandi Young Named SVP Of Sales For iHeartMedia Phoenix
Cumulus Media & Audioboom Announce Strategic Partnership
In Brief - July 1, 2015
June 30, 2015
iHeartRadio Takes Flight With Virgin America
Meredith Gardner & Josh Kahn Promoted To VPs of Digital Marketing & Product
In Brief - June 30, 2015
June 29, 2015
Alpha Media Louisville Names Otis Program Director/Afternoon Host At WDJX
Broadcasters Foundation Of America Names Dan Mason Co-Vice Chairman/Treasurer
JJ Kincaid Set To Wake Up Denver
BMG Acquires Verse Music Group
In Brief - June 29, 2015
June 26, 2015
eQB NOW
Sirius XM Agrees To Pay For Recordings Released Before 1972
Cumulus Names Troy Hanson PD At WKQX/Chicago
Brandon "Buster" Satterfield Joins Atlantic Records
June 25, 2015
Taylor Swift To Put 1989 On Apple Music
WLTW/New York To Celebrate 15 Years Of Broadway In Bryant Park
Report: Six Main Causes of Lost Quarter Hours
June 24, 2015
iHeartMedia Austin Names Zach Dillon Program Director For KHFI
Music News
Demi Lovato Is Feeling "Cool for the Summer"
Quick Hits: Rihanna, Taylor Swift / album sales, Prince
Rockers Breaking Benjamin Land Their First #1 Album
Quick Hits: Rihanna, Robin Thicke, Apple Music, Prince
Chris Brown, Beyoncé Top BET Award Winners
Quick Hits: Shinedown, Rob Thomas, Foo Fighters, AC/DC, Kings of Leon
Yes Bassist Chris Squire Passes Away
FMQB Photo Pass: Rush
Quick Hits: Demi Lovato, Jessie J, Billboard Hot 100 Music Festival
Beyonce & The Weeknd Headlining Made In America Festival
Quick Hits: Pharrell & Adele, Eminem / Southpaw soundtrack, Legacy of Hope concert
Quick Hits: Apple Music, Chris Brown
Quick Hits: Billboard 200, BET Awards, Smashing Pumpkins, Tyga, Riot Fest, The Neighbourhood, Marina and the Diamonds, Roger Waters
Disturbed Ends Four-Year Hiatus with Immortalized
Quick Hits: Janet Jackson, Nickelback, Tove Lo, Rod Stewart, Grateful Dead, James Horner, Hollywood Walk of Fame
FMQB NOW

Brian Mack, PD
WXXL/Orlando

Advertisement:
Search FMQB.com
Advertisements:
FMQB Member Login
Email:
Pass:

Save
Not a member yet?
Sign up Now!
Sign Up for Breaking News!
Enter FMQB E-Tracking!