CBS Argues That Halftime Show Was Not Indecent
September 12, 2007

At Tuesday's "nipplegate" hearing before the U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia, CBS Corp. argued that it should not be held liable for the 2004 Super Bowl halftime show that ended with Janet Jackson's breast-baring "wardrobe malfunction" because the stunt was both unscripted and unintended. CBS also said that if the FCC's $550,000 fine is upheld, it will effectively censor U.S. broadcasting. CBS lawyer Robert Corn-Revere urged the court to overturn the fine and said the ruling has had a "profoundly censorious effect" on U.S. broadcasting by deterring stations from showing material that could possibly be considered indecent, according to Reuters. The network feels that by fining them, the FCC has abandoned its policy of avoiding penalties for "fleeting" or "isolated" images.

However, FCC attorney Eric Miller defended the decision that the halftime show was indecent because it was a "highly sexualized performance" even before the brief breast exposure. Miller claims that CBS had been "willful" in its broadcast because it failed to guard against indecency. He said the National Football League had expressed concern beforehand about the sexually charged performance and that Jackson's choreographer said in advance the show would contain "some shocking moments." "CBS was indifferent to the fact that an obvious risk can constitute a deliberate omission," Miller argued, according to Reuters.

Miller also said that Jackson and halftime co-star Justin Timberlake were employees of CBS, therefore the network should have to pay for their actions. However, Julio Fuentes, one member of the three-judge panel, challenged that claim. "That doesn't make sense at all," Fuentes said, according to Reuters. "They were not employees of CBS, were they?"

The network immediately apologized after the incident aired and both Jackson and Timberlake confirmed they planned it "independently and clandestinely" without informing anyone, according to court documents. At the time, Jackson released a statement saying, "The decision to have a costume reveal at the end of my halftime show was made after final rehearsals. [Halftime show producer] MTV was completely unaware of it. It was not my intention that it go as far as it did."

The court is expected to rule in the coming months but it did not indicate exactly when.




 
Breaking News
Hubbard Radio Ups Jeremy Sinon To Corporate Digital Director
May 21, 2015
President Obama To Renominate Jessica Rosenworcel As FCC Commissioner
Herndon Hasty Joins Cumulus Kansas City As VP/Sales
In Brief - May 21, 2015
May 20, 2015
Bruce Lundvall, Longtime Blue Note President, Dies At 79
Zach Mullins Named Digital Sales Manager For Cox Media Group/Atlanta
Quality Control Music Signs Joint Venture With Capitol Music Group/Motown Records
Spotify Adds Video Content, Podcasts
In Brief - May 20, 2015
May 19, 2015
iHeartCommunications To Pay $1M For Misusing EAS Tones During The Bobby Bones Show
Nielsen Study: Radio Delivers Decision-Makers For American Family Insurance
Triton To Represent XAPP Ad Inventory For jācapps Broadcasters
Pandora To Acquire Next Big Sound
Deezer Expands Content With News, Entertainment and Sports Podcasts
Republic/Island Execs & Artists at the BMA’s
In Brief - May 19, 2015
May 18, 2015
Alpha Media To Purchase Morris Communications Radio Stations
"Party Ben" Gill Joins Pandora
Spanish Broadcasting System First Quarter 2015 Results
Communion Records US Signs Broad Agreement With Capitol Music Group
BMG Acquires US Rock Label Rise Records
In Brief - May 18, 2015
May 15, 2015
Mary Quass, Dan Vallie To Be Honored With The Conclave Rockwell Award For 2015
In Brief - May 15, 2015
May 14, 2015
Music News
Pitch Perfect 2 Comes In At #1
Quick Hits: Taylor Swift, Madonna, Little Mix, Roger Waters
Quick Hits: Foo Fighters, The Rolling Stones, Kanye West, Five Finger Death Punch, Amy Winehouse, Riot Fest
FMQB Photo Pass: MMRBQ 2015
Quick Hits: Sam Smith, B.B. King, Life Is Beautiful festival, Bullet For My Valentine
Taylor Swift Cleans Up at Billboard Music Awards
Chris Brown, Nicki Minaj Lead 2015 BET Awards Nominees
Quick Hits: Taylor Swift, Bob Dylan, Janet Jackson, Nick Jonas, Chinx
Blues Legend B.B. King Passes Away
FMQB Photo Pass: Radio 104.5 Birthday Show
Quick Hits: Eddie Vedder, Drake, U2, LouFest, Earl Sweatshirt
Mumford & Sons Earn Second #1 Album With Wilder Mind
Quick Hits: Pitbull & Chris Brown, Owl City, Jack White & Loretta Lynn, Tedeschi Trucks Band
Quick Hits: Britney Spears & Iggy Azalea, Billboard Music Awards, BMI Pop Awards / P!nk, Jennifer Lopez, Coldplay, BET Experience
Kanye Added To Billboard Music Awards, Receives Honorary Degree
FMQB NOW

Question Of
The Week

Advertisement:
Search FMQB.com
Advertisements:
FMQB Member Login
Email:
Pass:

Save
Not a member yet?
Sign up Now!
Sign Up for Breaking News!
Enter FMQB E-Tracking!