Supreme Court Won't Hear UMG-Eminem Royalty Case
March 22, 2011

The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to hear Universal Music Group's appeal of a lower court decision stemming from unpaid royalties to Eminem and F.B.T. Productions. According to the Detroit Free Press, the Supreme Court opting to pass on the case means that the previous lower court ruling stands, which could cost UMG between $40-50 million.

F.B.T. filed the suit in 2007, claiming that UMG's online deals are licensing agreements and the label should pay out 50 percent of net revenue on digital downloads. Universal argued that it owed F.B.T. the same royalty it pays on physical sales: 18 percent of the suggested retail price. The Detroit-based FBT administered Em's deal with UMG in 1998, and is still entitled to royalties from his music. Eminem himself was not a part of the suit.

"For us, this is probably a $40 million to $50 million issue," Joel Martin of F.B.T. told the Free Press. "Every artist who has this sort of language in their contract is now going to go back to their record company and say, ‘OK, so what do you want to do about [download royalties]?’"

There has been speculation that the results of this case could lead to changes across the industry when it comes to download royalties, with potentially higher payouts for acts whose contracts pre-date the MP3 era.

In a statement, Universal spokesman Peter Lofrumento said, "The case has always been about one agreement with very unique language. As it has been made clear during this case, the ruling has no bearing on any other recording agreement and does not create any legal precedent."

"We’ve been waiting for this from the Supreme Court, but we’ve been talking with the artists about it, and they’ve been very interested," Billy Wilson of the Motown Alumni Association told the Free Press."And it’s not just Motown artists, but many others in the same situation, who now have the same opportunity to renegotiate their contracts — and renegotiate the structure of the music industry, really."




 
Breaking News
Universal Music Group Extends Lucian Grainge
July 30, 2015
CBS Radio Extends Scott Shannon
iHeartMedia Reports Results For 2015 Second Quarter
Benztown Promotes Christopher "Jack" Johansing To Marketing Director
July 29, 2015
iHeartMedia Charlotte Names Keith Hotchkiss Market President
Pierre Bouvard: Radio's Delivers On Amazon Prime Day
In Brief - July 29, 2015
July 28, 2015
Cumulus Appoints Brian Thomas As PD For WLS-FM/Chicago
AT&T To Activate FM Chips On Android Smartphones
BroadbandTV & BMG Form Strategic Alliance To Support New Generation Of Music Artists
Chicago Radio Legend John Records Landecker To Sign Off After 40 Years On-Air
Cumulus-Buffalo Re-Signs Shredd and Ragan For Mornings At WEDG
Rare Job Ops at 98 Rock/Baltimore
In Brief - July 28, 2015
July 27, 2015
Emmis Announces Executive Promotions
iHeartRadio Joins Snapchat Discover
Pandora Listeners Receive More Uninterrupted Hours With Sponsored Listening
July 24, 2015
Radio Industry & SESAC Reach Settlement
The Week In Review: 7/20-7/24
CBS Radio Names David Yadgaroff As SVP/Market Manager For Philadelphia
In Brief - July 24, 2015
July 23, 2015
Frankie V. Heads Home To Boston
Major Changes at CBS RADIO
In Brief - July 23, 2015
Music News
Kanye, Sam Smith, The Who & Many More Announced For iHeartRadio Music Festival
Quick Hits: One Direction, Queen Latifah & Mary J. Blige, The Gaslight Anthem, Paul McCartney
FMQB Retro-Active: Ken Sharp Talks to Cherie Currie, and Reviews Live Releases From The Who and The Rolling Stones
Quick Hits: Dr. Dre, U2, Zayn Malik, Gary Clark Jr.
Macklemore Talks New Album, Relapse Into Drug Use
Quick Hits: Meghan Trainor, Justin Bieber, Janelle Monáe, Keith Richards, Lollapalooza, Chance The Rapper, Neil Young
Imagine Dragons, Jack Johnson Join Farm Aid 30
Quick Hits: Rise Against, Keith Richards, Puscifer, Judas Priest & Mastodon, Mat Kearney, Circa Survive
Rapper Future Hits #1 With Surprise Album
Quick Hits: U2 & Lady Gaga, Disclosure & Sam Smith, Ed Sheeran, Mariah Carey, Bobbi Kristina Brown, Guns N' Roses, Sevendust, Joseph Jackson
Ed Sheeran TV Special To Air On NBC
The Week In Review: 7/20-7/24
Quick Hits: Five Finger Death Punch, Prince, Meg Myers, The Grateful Dead
Quick Hits: Lil Wayne & Charlie Puth, Vance Joy, Lana Del Rey
Quick Hits: Selena Gomez, James Blake / Kanye West, Incubus
FMQB NOW

Jonathan Shuford, PD
WRVW/Nashville

Advertisement:
Search FMQB.com
Advertisements:
FMQB Member Login
Email:
Pass:

Save
Not a member yet?
Sign up Now!
Sign Up for Breaking News!
Enter FMQB E-Tracking!